Bourbon Ratings and Reviews

Montauk Distilling Co. 'Tunney' 4 Year Reserve Bourbon Whiskey

David 6/21/25

Discovered in the heart of wine country

Found near the North Fork vineyards this is a smooth, decent tasking bourbon from Long Island NY!

The Clover Single Barrel Straight Bourbon Whiskey

This is very smooth tasting .and is #3..

Bulleit Ten Year Old Small Batch Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Bulleit 10 Year Old Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Bulleit 10yr is my every go to.I find it smoother than the othe Bulleit line.
#9

Four Roses OESK Single Barrel Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

It’s Four Roses. It’s very smooth and won’t disappoint.
#7

Buffalo Trace Traveller Whiskey

This is #6 in my top 10.
Nice taste .very smooth and reasonable price

Blade & Bow Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

This is definitely #1 in my top 10.
Great taste excellent price
If your into blended this is the one.

Woodford Reserve Kentucky Derby® 151 Limited Edition Bourbon Whiskey (1L)

This is prob #5 in my top 10.very nice taste.

Freeland Spirits Bourbon Whiskey

This is a well rounded whiskey just complex enough to make it very interesting but still super smooth and easy to drink! Love the Pinot noir finish giving it a nice deep berry note along with the Carmel and vanilla expected in a bourbon. A good representation in its finish of how blending can up the ante of a whiskey and the Pinot finish from elk cove really gives it some of Oregons amazing terroir.
Everyone has a different palate but it’s nice to have a whiskey blended with a unique identity and not pay $90 for the bottle.

McAfee's Benchmark Old No. 8 Brand Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey (1.75L)

Decent bourbon with surprisingly good taste

Bought it on a whim and really like it straight up or in an Old Fashioned or Manhattan

Green River Distilling Co. Wheated Straight Bourbon Whiskey

BourbonSampler 2/14/25

Great sipping bourbon. Smooth finish. Great price for the quality.

Penelope Architect Straight Bourbon Whiskey

I am not a bourbon guy, but this is tremendous. Extremely smooth and complex (not sure how to explain flavor or taste!).

Jim Beam Winter Reserve Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

“Winter Edition” caught my attention. The spice notes made me order two bottles, one as a gift for my younger son and the other one for me. Keeping in mind a bottle of Jim Beam costs $17.00, would this be worth the price? My answer is yes it is! It’s smooth and the spice notes do come through. OK it doesn’t have the depth profile of most $50.00 bottles but I don’t mind saving $30 now and then and I’m about to order a couple more bottles. It IS 86 proof not 90 as posted. My son hasn’t opened his yet but I know his tastes at 27 years old and he’ll like it a lot.

Cooper's Mark Sugar House Maple-Flavored Bourbon Whiskey

iceskate6411 1/12/25

Only for Old Fashions with “general company.”

The maple flavor is very pronounced when you open the bottle. To use this bourbon with a “mixer” is almost a must. Not bad, just overwhelming by itself

Ole Smoky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

I’ve tasted Ole Smokey’s house bourbon alongside James Ownby Reserve, which is as smooth as it gets, and I honestly can’t tell the two apart!
Ole Smokey’s house bourbon whisky earns an absolute 10 in my humble opinion.

W.L. Weller Special Reserve Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Until internet "experts", flippers, speculators, and just plain folks suffering from FOMO overhyped this bourbon as the second coming of Pappy Van Winkle a few years ago, this was a solid, low proof, wheated bourbon that was well worth the $19.99 - $30 most shops charged for it. It is NOT worth the nearly $70 price for a 750ml bottle. As another reviewer mentioned, if you're looking for a solid wheated bourbon, don't fall for the hype. Maker's Mark Cask Strength can be had for around the same price point, and you get more bang (and flavor) for your buck. The Antique 107 version is a little better, but again, worth the $50 it was selling for less than a decade ago, not the nearly $200 it sells for today.

Yellow Rose Outlaw Bourbon Whiskey

Excellent Texas Bourbon

Excellent Texas distilled sipping Bourbon. A little bit on the sweet side but the long lasting tails were greatly appreciated.
This is a rebuy for sure and will keep proudly on my bourbon shelf!

Horse Soldier Premium Straight Bourbon Whiskey

So very Smoothe- No other words

I am no expert at all on Bourbons and just learning, but a local restaurant owner allowed me to try this one and I was absolutely amazed. So very smoothe. Then I researched the history, bought one as a gift and one for me. I will definitely make this a favorite!!

Peerless Double Oak Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Matrixman 11/26/24

Well all I’m gonna say is this maybe the new leader on my top 5 bourbons. Little pricey but this is one tasty bourbon. Already ordered 2 more bottles

Widow Jane Baby Jane Heirloom Corn Straight Bourbon Whiskey

I know there are bourbons with various wine casks influences but as far as straight bourbon smoothness this may be the best I’ve ever tasted especially for the price.

McAfee's Benchmark Old No. 8 Brand Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey (1.75L)

Surprising bourbon, especially for the price point. Pooukarity is going up as it’s hard to find in local stores. Usually priced between 21 and 24 dollars a handle locally, so a little surprised to see Caskers prices at approx 28. Give it a try, you won’t be disappointed.

15 Stars Private Stock 8 & 15 Year Old Straight Bourbon Whiskey

I saw a review from someone I watch on Youtube. They loved it. I did not. I would say pass. Sorry. Did not like this bottle.

Rabbit Hole Heigold Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Easy drinking. Not remarkable.

Not sure it's worth the price. Very smooth. Probably wouldn't buy it again. Too many other choices at this price point that I feel are better. Knob Creek 9 year would be a better buy.

Garrison Brothers Balmorhea Texas Straight Bourbon Whiskey

HarleyMtnMan 9/4/24

I fealt the same way chilepeepa did on his initial experience with GB. Not impressed and had a pallet I was not sure I liked all that much. Then I caved and bought a Guadalupe and then a Balmorea. I reall changed my mind. A great friend came by with a bottle of Cowboy. We got pretty hammered tasting all three. Then we started blending the 3 GB's we had. I knew we were snockered then. We had a blast. Too expensive to be experimenting blending your own though. LOL in conclusion yes I have come to really enjoy GB.

TX Straight Bourbon Whiskey

I honestly don't care for their blended whiskey but their straight bourbon is truly outstanding, especially for the price point. I enjoy drinking it neat, no hug, very smooth, lingering finish in a good way. I belong to a bourbon club, plan on blind tasting it down the road, quite confident this bourbon will score surprisingly well. Definitely will buy again.

Widow Jane Baby Jane Heirloom Corn Straight Bourbon Whiskey

LizzyJane 8/19/24

Slightly spicy sweet vanilla flavor with a smooth finish

Heaven's Door Straight Bourbon Whiskey

This is my favorite go to bourbon. I’ve not had super expensive bourbons but for the average person like myself this is one of the bests in my personal opinion. I’ve also had the HD Revelation and that was pretty tasty also. I just gave my neighbor and one of my good friends a bottle to try and they both loved it.

Eagle Rare 10 Year Old Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Eagle Rare Never Fails

Eagle Rare is an appropriate name for this bourbon as it is hard to find but well worth the wait when it is available!

Buffalo Trace Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

I love the taste of Buffalo Trace. I drank it on the rock or mixed with simply lemonade zero.

Widow Jane Baby Jane Heirloom Corn Straight Bourbon Whiskey

"intense, creamy flavor" ...? Intense = yes. Creamy = not even close. I can only describe it as a harsh with a bad flavor.
Knock the price down by $20, and it might be okay in cocktails (when serving folks you don't want 'waste' the good stuff on)

Elijah Craig Toasted Barrel Bourbon Whiskey

This is my go to in the fall, love the toasted notes and flavor. Perfect for sipping around the camp fire.

Jefferson's Tropics Singapore Straight Kentucky Bourbon Whiskey

Better than all the other Jefferson's I've had. Kind of addicting.

Buffalo Trace Traveller Whiskey

Smooth, flavorful, and not harsh at all. I will buy this again.

Brother's Bond Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Smooth, flavorful, and a good value. Highly recommend.

Buffalo Trace Traveller Whiskey

Learn about Blended Whiskey

I picked up a bottle of this based on a local store clerk’s recommendation. I immediately regretted not reading the label, which clearly stated “Blended Whiskey”. I have a keen sense of smell and did not detect the symphony of aromas touted in this product description. I know likes and dislikes are purely subjective so I’ll only say I found the flavor profile to be light, thin and hot. Not pleasant. If you aren’t a fan of grain neutral spirits you will not like this.

Warbringer Mesquite Smoked Southwest Bourbon Whiskey

This was hands down the worst bourbon I've ever had. It's like drinking liquid smoke.

Buffalo Trace Traveller Whiskey

You would think it would be similar to buffalo trace, it’s not even close. Instantly regret buying.

Black Button Bespoke Bourbon Cream

I first discovered this product at the Windmill shops in Yates County, New York. It’s simply delicious. The best bourbon cream I have tasted. I have gifted it to friends all over Capitol Hill from all parts of the US. The reviews are all glowing for the unique and versatile bourbon cream product.

Angel's Envy Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

As a person who loves a good bourbon, this was pretty good. Liked the finish and its pretty smooth. Good flavor straight and in an old fashion too.

Buffalo Trace Traveller Whiskey

Might want to pass on this one

I had immediate buyers remorse when I tried to sip on this. Terrible to be honest. It redeemed itself a bit later when I mixed it with Coke. It is actually smooth in Coke. As a sipper you are 1000 percent better off with the cheaper Buffalo Trace.

Noble Oak Double Oak Bourbon Whiskey

Great tasting double oak

Tried this out at a local establishment. Definitely impressed with the great notes that come through. Even more impressed that it is a sub $40 bottle. I'm on my third bottle and its one I look forward to pouring. Offered novice brother in law several other pours and this was the winner by far. Time for another bottle.

Buffalo Trace Traveller Whiskey

Buffalo Trace On Steroids

I totally disagree with “Marketing Gimmick”. This is Buffalo Trace but smoother and a hint of sweetness. Taking quality and price into consideration, and I am a bourbon connoisseur, I’m seriously considering making this my go to house bourbon.

Blanton's The Original Single Barrel Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Storm - NC 5/3/24

We all know finding this is like a Unicorn, it's just got to ordered online in NC. It's Blanton's and it really has to be one of the best, lots have been written but no matter what accept the positive and try it at least once! Bourbon Bucket List material, enjoy.

Blade & Bow Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

I rate this as a 9 plus and one of my repeat orders.

Willett Pot Still Reserve Straight Bourbon Whiskey

The Bottle Is Weird But Not The Bourbon

On my scale of 1-10 this is a 10 plus and for the price it goes on my repeat list.

W.L. Weller Special Reserve Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

One Of My Few Repeats

Weller proves a screw cap can cover a special bourbon. $70 is pretty much the top of my range these days but it’s hard to leave this one off my list.

Remus Straight Bourbon Whiskey

This bottle proves a cork isn’t necessary to contain a high quality bourbon. I maintain a 1-10 ratings list. This is an 11 for $40!

Heaven's Door Bootleg Series 2020 Limited Edition Gift Box

Look, it's a delicious bourbon, but it's not a thousand-dollar bottle. You're paying for the name more than the product itself.

W.L. Weller Special Reserve Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Good solid wheated bourbon

Good balance of taste. A sweet and not too hot of a finish. Paid a decent price considering the current bourbon market. Surprisingly fast shipping as I've had some orders take weeks to arrive.

Kentucky Owl Bourbon St. Patrick's Edition

Great value for the sale price

I got this on sale from Caskers. It’s a decent pour, and you can definitely get plenty of hints of that Irish Whiskey with it. It’s smooth and very drinkable, although not my cup of tea. For a limited release, the deal was very good on sale, and I am happy I got a bottle.

Coppersea Excelsior Bourbon Whisky

This is an excellent Bourbon.
Don't let the origin hold you back.
This a well-crafted spirit, with a charming palette, warm to the tongue and gentle to the throat.
We are very familiar with the Adirondack region of NYS, and this will be our favorite 'Camp Fire' Bourbon from now on.

All Bourbon reviews

Montauk Distilling Co. 'Tunney' 4 Year Reserve Bourbon Whiskey

The Clover Single Barrel Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Bulleit 10 Year Old Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Four Roses OESK Single Barrel Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Buffalo Trace Traveller Whiskey

Blade & Bow Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Woodford Reserve Kentucky Derby® 151 Limited Edition Bourbon Whiskey (1L)

Freeland Spirits Bourbon Whiskey

McAfee's Benchmark Old No. 8 Brand Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey (1.75L)

Green River Distilling Co. Wheated Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Penelope Architect Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Jim Beam Winter Reserve Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Cooper's Mark Sugar House Maple-Flavored Bourbon Whiskey

Ole Smoky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

W.L. Weller Special Reserve Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Yellow Rose Outlaw Bourbon Whiskey

Horse Soldier Premium Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Peerless Double Oak Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Widow Jane Baby Jane Heirloom Corn Straight Bourbon Whiskey

McAfee's Benchmark Old No. 8 Brand Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey (1.75L)

15 Stars Private Stock 8 & 15 Year Old Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Rabbit Hole Heigold Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Garrison Brothers Balmorhea Texas Straight Bourbon Whiskey

TX Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Widow Jane Baby Jane Heirloom Corn Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Heaven's Door Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Eagle Rare 10 Year Old Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Buffalo Trace Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Widow Jane Baby Jane Heirloom Corn Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Elijah Craig Toasted Barrel Bourbon Whiskey

Jefferson's Tropics Singapore Straight Kentucky Bourbon Whiskey

Buffalo Trace Traveller Whiskey

Brother's Bond Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Buffalo Trace Traveller Whiskey

Warbringer Mesquite Smoked Southwest Bourbon Whiskey

Buffalo Trace Traveller Whiskey

Black Button Bespoke Bourbon Cream

Angel's Envy Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Buffalo Trace Traveller Whiskey

Noble Oak Double Oak Bourbon Whiskey

Buffalo Trace Traveller Whiskey

Blanton's The Original Single Barrel Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Blade & Bow Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Willett Pot Still Reserve Straight Bourbon Whiskey

W.L. Weller Special Reserve Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Remus Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Heaven's Door Bootleg Series 2020 Limited Edition Gift Box

W.L. Weller Special Reserve Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Kentucky Owl Bourbon St. Patrick's Edition

Coppersea Excelsior Bourbon Whisky