Whiskey Ratings and Reviews

Black Fly Bourbon

Armitage 10/3/22

Unfortunately… not great.

I’m an avid whiskey fan. Bourbon, Scotch, Irish. I enjoy quality in just about everything. Imagine my disappointment when the whisky distilled just down the street from me was one one of the worst I’ve ever tried. I was actually angry because it is priced the same as some of the best whisky in the world. It has been aged for under a year and is very apparent on the palette although I can’t see that the new make they use was worth putting in the barrel in the first place. It tastes somewhat like tepid water that has been sitting in a wooden cup for a day. Severely dissatisfied.

Yellowstone Select Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Best value for your money and ease of use to find. This is my “house” bourbon. I cant find better quality and availability than this gem. I am upset right now writing this review because i just finished my last drop of it i had in the house. So now i am drinking a more expensive bottle that doesnt please me the way this one does. Go Yellowstone!

Blanton's Straight From The Barrel Bourbon Whiskey

Great tasting Bourbon!

Great Bourbon when you can find it!

Black Butte Malt Whiskey

CowPoleon 9/17/22

Best American Whiskey

Black butte is easily one of the smoothest whiskies I’ve had the pleasure to try.

We always keep at least 2 bottles in the house haha

Redbreast Lustau Edition Single Pot Still Irish Whiskey

Exceptional value. Great taste.

My wife purchased the Redbreast Lustau Edition and I find it exceptional in taste, I think that it some ways it tastes better and is more aromatic and pleasing than my much more expensive 21 years old Irish whiskey. I was skeptical at first and asked her not to purchase the Lustau. I am very happy that she made the purchase. This Irish whiskey is such an exceptional value. I highly recommend you give it a try.

Orphan Barrel Fable & Folly 14 Year Old Whiskey

This has quickly become my favorite whiskey!

Rebel Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Crazy Eddie 8/23/22

How is this so cheap?

Super smooth and undoubtedly my go to Bourbon of choice. I am constantly amazed at how inexpensive this Bourbon is and wonder that its just because so many people haven't tried it yet. Straight, over ice or in a mixed drink this is the best Bourbon to cost ratio I have ever found.

Breckenridge Madeira Cask Finish Batch 1 Bourbon Whiskey

Smooth and delicious -

Redbreast 27 Year Old Single Pot Still Irish Whiskey

I'm not kidding when I say 5 of us were all very excited to try this, being huge redbreast fans, and we all had the exact same reaction to the finish, it tastes like green onions. I didn't say a word waiting to see if anyone else noticed, but we all said the same. Stick with the excellent other redbreast choices.

The Whistler Beekeepers Select Irish Honey

I don't understand why more stores don't sell it

I've tried several honey whiskeys and find the whistlers to be the most smooth flavorful easy on the palate than any of the others! It's Aroma and flavor and aftertaste is exquisite for a honey flavored whiskey! Paul S

Wyoming Whiskey Double Cask

Smooth and just sweet enough

I really enjoyed this bottle. It is more complex than the regular bourbon, but is very smooth with a sweeter finish. A hint of vanilla and cinnamon are highlights. On the rocks is great as it settles down the 100 proof and extends the experience. Will definitely buy again!

Woodford Reserve Baccarat Edition

i have been looking for a bottle of woodford reserve baccarat edition for sale but could not find one at such good price i will definitely be ordering

Rabbit Hole Dareringer Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Scotch and bourbon ( & wine) fan 6/25/22

I first tried Rabbit Hole Dareringer when on the Bourbon Trail. What a great distillery and whiskey. Take the tour if you are in the area. I bought several bottles of which Darringer was one of my favorites. A great taste, smooth & enjoyable. I was happy to see it available at Caskers so I could restock!

Noble Oak Double Oak Bourbon Whiskey

I am totally addicted

Love the rounded flavor. It's hard to make the bottle last more than a weekend. Glad I tried it. Have bought a few more bottles. Will continue to have it around for a special treat.

Glen Moray 25 Year Old Port Cask Finish Single Malt Scotch Whisky

This was so good. I am in mourning that I cant find any more. I am down to last two bottles.

GlenDronach 12 Year Old Original Scotch Whisky

Viking Dust 6/8/22

One of my favorites of all time

It's up there with Oban 14. Fantastic if you love Single Malts with Sherry casked finishes.

Freeland Spirits Bourbon Whiskey

I was baffled there wasn't a poor review of this whiskey that existed so I really felt compelled to keep people from buying this as a gift. I hear their Gin is pretty decent but this whiskey is hot and unbalanced. It's described as having a clove back-bone, but really, the pinot barrel made the juice a bit too cloying and ethanol-forward. Acrid, sour, spicy, and unbalanced, and unpalatable. They may have just cut the tails of the run weird on the batch that I received which may be a one-off because my suspicion is it came out at cask-stregnth and not 46%. That being said, I cut it with a lot of water to try to save the dram and it was still undrinkable.

Reminds me of an Irish whiskey which would make sense from a distillery that started with a Gin focus. The age (3years) isn't too bad, but Freeland's methodology needs a lot of rehashing or barrels need some serious rectification to bring more balance to this bottle and we may honestly throw it away.

The Sassenach Blended Scotch Whisky

Avery nice blended scotch

This is a very balanced, flavorful scotch. It isn’t too smokey for those that do not like Islay scotch, but it does have some nice, smokey tones. It isn’t overly sweet. Its just a very nice whisky to enjoy. The price is a bit high for. Blended scotch, and that may keep it from being a regular go-to whisky, but its well worth buying a bottle to enjoy.

Noah's Mill Small Batch Kentucky Bourbon Whiskey

Tough Little Bourbon 5/27/22

Harsher as time goes on

I'm not one to refrigerate my bourbon, preferring a room temperature shot from time to time. The first notes of Noah's were wonderful. There was a soft heat and the fruity notes were lovely. As time went on and we got closer to the bottom of the bottle, it heated. Harshly. We are not aficionados and perhaps didn't treat this whiskey quite right, but that last shot was really tough. I might take to refrigerating in the future ...

Nikka From The Barrel Japanese Whisky

Mixing Bourbon 5/27/22

Not for shots or neat

We had high hopes for Nikka as we were looking for something a bit more refined than what we were buying from our usual haunts. However, it seemed neither timeless (per the description) or particularly classic. As a shot or neat in a glass, it had a medicinal quality that I truly attempt to avoid. I was able to do so by using it only making mixed drinks with it. We love the bottle, but won't be buying again at this price point.

Old Forester Statesman Straight Bourbon Whiskey

amazingly smooth drink it neat

amazingly smooth drink it neat for a complex easily drinkable bourbon you will order more

Dimple Pinch 15 Year Old Blended Scotch Whisky

Most underrated whiskey on the market, pleasant nose and nearly no burn on the way down. I feel that if it was entered into the right category, it could become the next pappy van winkle. Well worth the money, wish I could find it on store shelves.

Woodinville Bourbon Port Cask Finished

This is a 9 on my personal scale but the price really makes up for that last point; it’s a great value. Living in NJ I see that I can’t order it now so I’ll savor it while I can.

Woodford Reserve Double Oaked Straight Bourbon Whiskey

If I could rate this 4.5 I would. The double oak gives it a deep extraordinary flavor and the bourbon is very smooth. My personal preference is leave out double oak but other than that it’s a five star bourbon.

The Whistler Imperial Stout Cask Finish Irish Whiskey

Not what I was expecting from a stout aged Irish. There’s an odd funk to it, almost a sour note. Like a bier de garde ale or something. A bit disappointed.

Jack Daniel Distillery Sinatra Select Limited Edition Tennessee Whiskey

Jack Daniel's Sinatra Select Tennessee Whiskey

I bought this for very special occasions with my two sons. I'll write a true review massive after Father's day. I bought two, one will just be added to my Jack Daniels collection.

Heaven's Door Trilogy

I can't really give a review.

I bought this as a collectible

Three Chord Strange Collaboration Blended Bourbon Whiskey

Full smooth flavor. Great value.

Iron Smoke Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Like a campfire, and goes down smooth. First time I has this and now I get this instead of long islands. It has a hint of sweet, not enough to be there but just a tip. For those who don’t like a strong alcohol taste. I’ll buy it more if it was cheaper.

Colonel E.H. Taylor Jr. Small Batch Bourbon Whiskey

Incredibly smooth and high quality

If you can find it at retail grab it right away, buy as many as you can. This is one of my top 5 favorite bourbons. I Save this bottle for special occasions and treat good friends to what a special bourbon should taste like.

Jack Daniel's Sinatra Select Tennessee Whiskey

I am a long time drinker of "Old No 7" and when I first heard about "Sinatra", when it first came out, I ordered a bottle and oh man, it was "Nectar of the Gods!" So smooth, definitely a fine "sippin" whiskey.

I ordered another bottle for my SIL, a man who has everything, and it was a big hit with him, too. One of these days, I'm going to order another bottled but I highly recommend this for any whiskey aficionado where money is no issue.

Blanton's Original Single Barrel Bourbon Whiskey

Best Bourbon I've Tried

I've tried quite a bit of bourbon and I feel this one was worth every penny. Have yet to find any comparison at a reasonable price. Money well spent.

Old Rip Van Winkle 10 Year Old 107 Proof Bourbon Whiskey

Fantastic. Secondary is what it is

Van Winkle Special Reserve Lot "B" 12 Year Old Bourbon Whiskey

The whiskey is delicious. People whine about secondary saying it should be cheaper, but the market has spoken. They’re so delusional to think they would be able to buy it at retail price if places didn’t charge secondary. Dumb dumbs

Bulleit Bourbon Single Barrel (Caskers Staff Pick)

A wonderful surprise!

Really good. Wasn't expecting such a sweet ride, from beginning to end. Fruity, inviting nose. Punched with sweetness, strawberry, vanilla, spice, licorice on palate. Lingered well. Hit hotter than proof suggested, which I like. Went back to get second bottle...too late. Darn. Won't sleep on next offering...will order right away in the hope that it is similar to this barrell. Cheers!

Very Old Barton Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey (750mL)

Johnnybdrinking 4/26/22

An excellent pour for the money!

I've always been a fan of VOB, so I was excited to try the 100 proof version, and it did not disappoint! You get great flavor this low price bourbon, I think I'll order a few more.

Johnny Drum Private Stock Kentucky Bourbon Whiskey

A Solid Kentucky Whiskey

Maple syrup and spice on the nose; caramel and dark maple syrup on the tongue, followed by rye and pepper at the finish. A good corn liquor that mixes well.

Stillhouse Mint Chocolate Chip Moonshine

Great Taste!! 4/23/22

Get tasting moonshine. I will buy it again!

Goes great over ice!

Buffalo Trace Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

The Best Value On My Shelf

This bourbon has a superior pedigree and in this form, Buffalo Trace, it scores a 10 on my personal scale making it a bargain for the price.

Horse Soldier Barrel Strength Bourbon Whiskey

I bought it for the story, but I'll go back for the taste.
I don't have a sophisticated taste for bourbon. I rarely sip. I'm more of a shooter. But I know what I like, and so does my partner. Whenever I try something new, she "tries" it first. Not being a drinker, she dips her finger in it, then does the taste test. Then she gives me the yay or nay.
Horse Soldier Bourbon received a definite yay.
A little more expensive than what I normally buy, but worth the cost.

Ole Smoky Blackberry Moonshine

Moonshine 4/21/22

Willett Pot Still Reserve Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Usually when the bottle is fancy the contents leave a lot to be desired. Not this time, this bourbon is very smooth with great flavor. My personal rating is a score of 10. I’ll always have it on my shelf.

Bowman Brothers Pioneer Spirit Virginia Straight Bourbon Whiskey

The Glenlivet Archive 21 Year Old Single Malt Scotch Whisky

Disappointing and overpriced.

"Rich, luxurious aroma of pine, raisins and sandalwood. Notes of brown sugar, walnuts and honey on the palate, that are well-complemented by notes of dried fruits, Christmas cake and baking spices. Finish is long and sweet, with a hint of chewy leather, ginger and oak". Quite a list of 'tastes' that are not apparent nor discernible. Fruit, Christmas Cake and spices, walnuts, brown sugar, pine, honey, raisins, sandalwood, ginger, oak and a 'hint' of chewy leather. Snobbish trash talk for all the hints I gather is chewy leather with the typical Scotch aroma predominant. I will say it is smooth and the finish does linger a bit and that's the best I can do.. I'm not new to Scotch Whiskey blended or single malt and I've been imbibing for over 60 years. Whiskey is NOT wine. Trying to give it all these superlatives like a well aged bottle of vintage wine is an exercise in futility. I had my first bottle of Glenlivet 12 year old, back in '75. The taste has never been the same since. Back then, Single Malts were not the 'in' thing to drink and describing all the 'hints' of flavors contained therein would have made whiskey drinkers laugh. Quality, to my mind and taste has gone down hill due to mass production and demand. I was expecting something very special with this 21 year old Scotch. It's not much different then an ordinary bottle of 12 year old. In short, if you are thinking of spending 25 thousand dollars for a bottle of 50 year old, I suggest you demand a wee dram prior to your purchase.

Jameson Original Irish Whiskey

Great tasting whiskey. I will buy again!!

Ezra Brooks Straight Rye Whiskey

Ran a taste test with Ezra rye n wt101 rye. For the price and only .6 proof difference. Ezra is just as good. ..I like it..

Woodinville Straight Bourbon Whiskey

I don’t pretend to ascertain flavors; I just know which ones do not bite and have a lingering mouth feel to go along with flavor. For the price this belongs on everyone’s shelf. I rate it a 10.

The Sassenach Blended Scotch Whisky

A little bit of peat, a little bit of smoke, and lots of complex flavor. Look, I am not the guy who can tell you, "....this has notes of vanilla, apricot and fresh cherries". I simply lack the ability to differentiate flavors like some people can. What I can tell you is this is a very nice whisky. It has a light body and a very pleasing aftertaste. A friend of mine said it was "too sweet" for his tastes, but I thoroughly enjoyed it. I do believe the price is a little high, but that didn't keep me from ordering two more bottles.

Enjoy!

Iron Smoke Casket Strength Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Kinda taste like liquid charcoal. Originally thought for the price a good sipping whiskey. Use it for Kentucky Mules now

1792 Full Proof Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Stout, Bold and Smooth

Strong and full of flavor, this bold bourbon boasts an incredible deep and smoky taste, superbly balanced with sweet vanilla and notes of caramel. One of Sazerac's Most Underrated Bourbons

All Whiskey reviews

Black Fly Bourbon

Yellowstone Select Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Blanton's Straight From The Barrel Bourbon Whiskey

Black Butte Malt Whiskey

Redbreast Lustau Edition Single Pot Still Irish Whiskey

Orphan Barrel Fable & Folly 14 Year Old Whiskey

Rebel Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Breckenridge Madeira Cask Finish Batch 1 Bourbon Whiskey

Redbreast 27 Year Old Single Pot Still Irish Whiskey

The Whistler Beekeepers Select Irish Honey

Wyoming Whiskey Double Cask

Woodford Reserve Baccarat Edition

Rabbit Hole Dareringer Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Noble Oak Double Oak Bourbon Whiskey

Glen Moray 25 Year Old Port Cask Finish Single Malt Scotch Whisky

GlenDronach 12 Year Old Original Scotch Whisky

Freeland Spirits Bourbon Whiskey

The Sassenach Blended Scotch Whisky

Noah's Mill Small Batch Kentucky Bourbon Whiskey

Nikka From The Barrel Japanese Whisky

Old Forester Statesman Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Dimple Pinch 15 Year Old Blended Scotch Whisky

Woodinville Bourbon Port Cask Finished

Woodford Reserve Double Oaked Straight Bourbon Whiskey

The Whistler Imperial Stout Cask Finish Irish Whiskey

Jack Daniel's Sinatra Select Tennessee Whiskey

Heaven's Door Trilogy

Three Chord Strange Collaboration Blended Bourbon Whiskey

Iron Smoke Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Colonel E.H. Taylor Jr. Small Batch Bourbon Whiskey

Jack Daniel's Sinatra Select Tennessee Whiskey

Blanton's Original Single Barrel Bourbon Whiskey

Old Rip Van Winkle 10 Year Old 107 Proof Bourbon Whiskey

Van Winkle Special Reserve Lot "B" 12 Year Old Bourbon Whiskey

Bulleit Bourbon Single Barrel (Caskers Staff Pick)

Very Old Barton Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey (750mL)

Johnny Drum Private Stock Kentucky Bourbon Whiskey

Stillhouse Mint Chocolate Chip Moonshine

Buffalo Trace Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Horse Soldier Barrel Strength Bourbon Whiskey

Ole Smoky Blackberry Moonshine

Willett Pot Still Reserve Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Bowman Brothers Pioneer Spirit Virginia Straight Bourbon Whiskey

The Glenlivet Archive 21 Year Old Single Malt Scotch Whisky

Jameson Original Irish Whiskey

Ezra Brooks Straight Rye Whiskey

Woodinville Straight Bourbon Whiskey

The Sassenach Blended Scotch Whisky

Iron Smoke Casket Strength Straight Bourbon Whiskey

1792 Full Proof Straight Bourbon Whiskey