hero image

Caskers is a one-stop shop owned by Flaviar that specializes in curating an excitingly diverse collection of spirits and Champagne. From rare expressions to the most beloved bottles – there’s something here for everybody. We collect feedback on the Caskers experience from various channels – directly from our customers via social media as well as industry-relevant media – on the quality of our portfolio and customer service, and provide you with the latest and most credible insight. Check out our services’ ratings and reviews for yourself, open a nice bottle, and join the ranks of our satisfied customers!

How’s our Trustpilot score?

Take it from a third-party platform with your best decision-making in mind. See how high we scored on a scale on 1 - 5 and, more importantly, read why. No time like the present, explore the testimonials now.

What our customers

are saying

Media Features

We’re not as good at dropping names as we are at dropping fresh drams in our shop. Still, it’s worth mentioning that our expertise in locating unicorns didn’t go unnoticed by the spirits community and its outlets. By unicorns, we mean rare and exclusive bottles, of course. And by the community, we mean the Wine Enthusiast, The Manual, and The Whiskey Wash. See what’s the word on the world wide web:

Reviews by Expression

On the hunt for a specific bottle? Make sure you get the right one by checking the reviews on it first.

Jack Daniel's Single Barrel Tennessee Rye Whiskey

Jack Daniel's Single Barrel Tennessee Rye Whiskey

Uh...yeah
Quality
40%
Value
100%
Price
100%
This review is based on a four-ounce pour in a Glen Caron glass with two frozen medicinal stainless steel balls, medical grade. Poured this, let it sit 15 minutes, went to it multiple times to experience the scent in the glass. It is unlike any rye I have ever smelled. I can't even. Cherry leather. Can't compare to anything. Medicinal cherry flavored shoelace. Digging in deep on the nose. Deep inhale. Maybe brown sugar, but it's not pleasant. It smells like glue. It smells like I'm sniffing glue. Paint thinner, I must drink a lot of water with this one. Oh dear god, this is clearly an experiment. Drinking water now. Heavy Marzipan this was rye where they were like, oh, we gotta get rid of this. Let's quickly make a mash bill. hiccuping... I have never smelled anything like this before. I can't even say that I smell oak. Heavy deep sniffs, I smell oak.It that's it Oak Rye, light cherry, marzipan, and we're done. I don't want to drink the rest of this, but it's Halloween. It's not sweet. It's oaky medicinal, too high of a proof even at 47% Adding water now..... 25 oz... Cola... I can't I can't like this. I don't like it I'm gonna I'm gonna finish this because I poured it But I don't like it and I'm leaving this bottle probably forever at three quarters full. This is so unique of an expression that I can't wrap my head around it. It doesn't taste like rye. It tastes like a spiced bourbon. And they messed up on it and were trying to make some money off of it Probably because the barrels were somewhere in the rickhouse where they were like we forgot about these ones, well make a special release.
Meili Vodka

Meili Vodka

The BEST Thanksgiving Dinner Ever.
Quality
95.555555555556%
Value
95.555555555556%
Price
98.888888888889%
I had a whole bottle unto myself during the course of my Thanksgiving dinner. It was Screwdrivers all night. I'll admit, that didn't do this absolutely amazing Vodka any justice. However, stick with me for just a second.

All night long I had Family & Friends coming and going. Food was on the table, and it just kept going. All told we had about 25 - 40 people come through the house. It was magical. All night long, I was drinking my Vodka & OJ one after the other. It wasn't until after I finished the bottle off that I realised I had DRANK THE WHOLE BOTTLE..... Oops. The funny thing, I didn't feel like I was plastered like I normally would. I've spent many a nights stumbling around, my knees hate me. I was on top of the world, feeling absolutely alive. Green Flag #1.

Well, 2am rolls around. Sure enough, my stomach had had enough, and it was time to vacate the excess from my system. Off to the porcelain throne, to pay my respects. It was only a mouthful, and it was almost completely orange juice. It didn't hurt, it didn't burn, it didn't smell bad, it didn't even taste bad. IT DIDN'T TASTE BAD .... Green Flag #2...

Now for the real test of a new alcohol. I already tracked that I drank the whole bottle, and made a small donation. Time to see how life was going to be on the final end of this Adventure. I normally take 2 bottles of water and a couple Ibuprofen to make sleeping and wake up less of a painful experience. I figured I had already done this much unintentional personal research into how this was going to affect me and my habits. Might as well see how the sun feels later. I went to bed without taking any medication for recovery. No water, No electrolytes, No Medicines. We're doing it live, and we're doing it RAW.

I woke up absolutely on top of the world. The BEST mood, NO HANGOVER, or any other side effects from what I could tell. The Sun was bright and shining, the sounds were all normal, and I felt great. I walked out and greeted everyone with a cheery smile and they were all astonished I wasn't a half dead zombie. Green Flag #3.

This is the ONLY vodka that I will give my money to anymore. It's what I ask for at bars, and if it's not there I default to an Old Fashioned, tt's a classic that's hard to mess up (it happened recently ...) I no longer suffer any other Vodka. It's Meili, I've found my drink.
Everclear 190 Proof (1.75L)

Everclear 190 Proof (1.75L)

TOXIC WASTE
Quality
90%
Value
90%
Price
87.5%
I usually purchase the smaller Everclear in the glass bottle to make my medicinals for loved ones at Christmas. I though I'd save a few dollars this time and order the large bottle. So imagine my surprise and shock when I received the large Everclear, finally got the pillow plastic off, wondering why liquid was leaking out of the lid while fighting with the plastic pillow off, then saw that this large bottle is made of soft plastic, so every time I pulled on the pillow cover, the pressure would push liquid out of the soft plastic bottle. That was annoying, but not the worst thing. I think people who purchase everclear in plastic bottles should know that nanoplastic leaches into the everclear because of its volatility/high alcohol content, and what you get is a highly toxic concoction of nanoplastics that NO ONE should ever consume, as nanoplastics cross the blood-brain barrier and cause a number of medical issues. That being said, there was no way I was going to make my medicinals with the TOXIC liquid inside this plastic bottle, and I had no time to find another vendor to purchase everclear from in time for Christmas, so I went empty handed to my friends' and family members' homes. I had a lot of very disappointed people who had been looking forward to this tradition. So just know that unless you enjoy drinking nanoplastics, you might want to pass this one by and get the smaller, more expensive everclear in the glass bottle. It would have been nice if the description had stated that it was in a plastic bottle.
Delord 25 Year Old Bas Armagnac

Delord 25 Year Old Bas Armagnac

Best spirit Ive ever had the pleasure of enjoying
Quality
100%
Value
100%
Price
97.142857142857%
I dont even know where to start. Im more of a bourbon drinker but this armagnac is a perfect dance between the fruity white grape notes that youd typically get from cognac and the more rugged oak and leather notes that you find in many bourbons. It is truly an experience do be able to enjoy a 25 year bottle of booze without going broke. The nose is green apple, white grape, chocolate. The palate is unbeleivably complex with raisins, caramel, vanilla, oak, earthy, the list goes on and on. The finish is very oak, vanilla and chocolate. Like a dark cocoa cocoa german chocolate. I bought two more bottles after my first glass just because I know armagnac isnt always easy to come by. Again, words dont do justice to this bottle and as a bourbon drinker I have included this in my top occasion bottles.
Crystal Head Aurora Vodka

Crystal Head Aurora Vodka

Vodka is as individual as a bottle of wine
Quality
60%
Value
60%
Price
60%
If you’re not experienced in vodka and how it’s made, don’t randomly buy anything without trying it at a bar or a friends house, etc.
Vodka can be corn, wheat, potato based as well as a few other fermentable sources of carbohydrates. The water that is mixed with the “liquor” is equally important as is how it’s served (quality ice for instance).
My palate prefers wheat vodka. Yours may not.
This is a beautiful example of wheat based vodka that is best enjoyed over some quality ice (I prefer ice chips for this Aurora). Grey Goose is also wheat based. And it doesn’t compare in flavor to Aurora. I like GG & tonic and enjoy. I’d never put Aurora in tonic or any mixer.
Get vodka educated before your give a 1 star review.
BTW, I tried this at my cousins house over Christmas holiday 2023. She gave me a healthy pour over ice (too much). But, I dug in and finished that glass because after the first sip, I knew it was for me.
Corsair Gin-Head Style American Gin

Corsair Gin-Head Style American Gin

Our favorite for many years
Quality
100%
Value
100%
Price
100%
I’m always surprised to see how little known this June is. No one had even written a review. It’s hands down at the very top of my list. But I do need to qualify that statement.

The real test of gin is in an extra-dry martini (or gibson for me.). I use a vegetable oil sprayer to just coat the inside of a chilled martini glass with vermouth and immediately pour in the ice cold gin, so it’s as close to straight gin as you get. I actually prefer other gins with tonic but in a martini there’s nothing better.

I discovered it by accident when it was one of 6 gins my son-in-law and his business partner gave me years ago in appreciation for some help I gave their company. When we tasted it we were surprised that every single one of us liked this the best of the group—which included several well-known brands—and since then we continue to agree that it’s our favorite.

It’s not expensive and you should give it a try.
Jack Daniel's Sinatra Select Tennessee Whiskey

Jack Daniel's Sinatra Select Tennessee Whiskey

So many personalities in one bottle - all of them delicious!
Quality
90%
Value
85%
Price
90%
I bought Sinatra because my S.O. loves whiskey (I am just learning to love whiskey) and we both love mid century crooners. Our first shot is always neat. The first sip of Sinatra was like swallowing fireworks. It just kept blooming and blooming. Not hot. Not harsh. Just delightful. Gradually I started tasting and smelling the full spectrum of flavors and scents. It takes me a long time to drink a shot of whiskey and that’s good because after an hour the tobacco and orange flavors were taking center stage. My S.O. put an ice cube in his second dram and he said it opened it up. It was not an improvement; more a whole new, equally good, experience. We drank the bottle down a good few inches in just two evenings. I probably should have written my review a few weeks ago but I had to wait until I had a chance to order a second bottle. I didn’t want the word to get out and the stock to disappear. This is definitely in our Top Three. I hope to be able to find it still in stock when Bottle #2 begins to get low.
Buffalo Trace Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Buffalo Trace Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

15 years and still counting
Quality
98.545454545455%
Value
97.454545454545%
Price
95.636363636364%
I have been drinking Buffalo Trace bourbon whisky for about 15 years, and let me just say, it exceeded all my expectations as always. From the moment I poured a glass, I knew I was in for a treat. The aroma alone is enough to captivate your senses, with hints of oak, caramel, and just a touch of spice. But it's the taste that truly stole the show. Smooth, rich, and incredibly satisfying, each sip dances on the palate, delivering layers of complexity that keep you coming back for more. Whether enjoyed neat or in a classic cocktail, this bourbon stands out as a true testament to craftsmanship. Needless to say, it has earned a permanent place in my liquor cabinet. If you're a bourbon enthusiast like myself, do yourself a favor and add this gem to your collection. You won't be disappointed. Cheers to exceptional bourbon!
Buffalo Trace Traveller Whiskey

Buffalo Trace Traveller Whiskey

Best Whiskey Bottle
Quality
64.444444444444%
Value
66.666666666667%
Price
80%
I found myself in search of a new whiskey bottle. I do have to admit the name of this bottle is what first attracted me to it!
Traveller is the name of an album by Chris Stapleton. A country singer to which I have tickets for an upcoming concert.
So I thought why not let’s try out this bottle.
Now im not biased & this is my honest review. I received this bottle in less than 3 days. Purchased it Sunday afternoon & got it on a Wednesday. Packaging was great & bottle was unscathed upon delivery.
I opened the bottle & took in the aroma. It has a soft, smooth yet a little bit sweet smell to it.
I served a neat shot sized amount in a glass, and drank. When I tell you the aroma is just how it tasted! It’s the most perfect blend of smooth yet with a hint of sweetness to it. But it is not an overpowering sweetness, it is just perfect. The sweetness derives from a small caramel hint.
I’d have to say this bottle should be owned by every whiskey connoisseur out there.
If you know about Colonel E.H Taylor Jr Small Batch, a higher priced bottle yet the best I’ve had yet. This Traveller bottle is my runner up. For the taste & even better the price. It’s a win win. You win with the price tag & win with the flavor.
Now quit reading & add it to your cart. Thank me later!
Hirsch The Horizon Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Hirsch The Horizon Straight Bourbon Whiskey

This was just not it
Quality
40%
Value
40%
Price
40%
I was in my local store, i explained to the man behind the counter what i did like, Jim Beam was a classic, Jameson is avalbile at every bar, Angels Envy is just fine in my cabinet, Old Forster statesman is lovely i have a recipe for french toast with old forester, Buffalo is a nice treat when you can find it. I could go on. But. He sugessted this. That it would just change my life and open my eyes if i bought this bottle of Hirsch. So I did, he was so adament, probably about early 40s so i figured he knew what he was talking about.
I tried it as a shot, i tried it on the rocks, i tried it out of the freezer, the fridge, i even tried cooking several dishes with it. This stuff ruins everything. I wouldnt even clean a wound with this stuff in the zombie Apocalypse. If you like it more power to you, but finally after 2 weeks of fighting with it i finally poured it on the ground because i didnt want my septic tank to get an upset stomach.
Stillhouse Original Whiskey

Stillhouse Original Whiskey

Rethink your Whiskeys
Quality
80%
Value
100%
Price
100%
So there's something about pouring your Whiskey out of a tin with a screw top. It's not the same as some fancy green glass bottle with a snazzy cork. But I attended this one event for years. There was a bit of whiskey snobbery going on. I was told off for adding a splash of water to my glass of whatever-fancy-whiskey.... So one year, I started bringing a tin of Stillhouse, and I swear, the darn thing was empty within an hour or so.

So I am not a mixer.... I usually take my whiskey straight, or with a splash. But I like Stillhouse straight up. And I won't lie... it kicks like a grumpy mule all the way down... but it is wonderful ! Just take it a bit at a time and you will enjoy a punch in the face at first... but a firm and almost subtle after taste. I sense a very slight vanilla overtone in the first few sips. Others reported flavors of wood (in a good way). At any rate, no tin of Stillhouse has gone unappreciated, so highly recommended.
W.L. Weller Special Reserve Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

W.L. Weller Special Reserve Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Bourbon Weller Blue is a triumph, a testament to the skill and dedication of those who created it
Quality
92.857142857143%
Value
81.428571428571%
Price
80%
It is with great pleasure and utmost decorum that I pen this review for the Bourbon Weller Blue. The discerning connoisseur of fine spirits will no doubt find much to savor in this remarkable libation.

The Bourbon Weller Blue boasts a rich, amber hue that betrays the depth and complexity of its flavor. Upon nosing, one is greeted with a symphony of aromas, ranging from the sweet notes of honey and vanilla, to the warm, toasted oak that infuses the spirit with its distinctive character.

Upon first taste, one is struck by the remarkable smoothness of this bourbon, which is surprising given its robust and full-bodied nature. Rich and layered notes of caramel and brown sugar are offset by a subtle hint of spice, leading to a long and satisfying finish that lingers on the palate.

The Bourbon Weller Blue is an exemplar of the bourbon distiller's craft, a true masterpiece that bears witness to the artistry and passion of its creators. It is a spirit that rewards the discerning palate, and is sure to impress even the most fastidious of bourbon enthusiasts.

In short, the Bourbon Weller Blue is a triumph, a testament to the skill and dedication of those who created it. It is a spirit that speaks to the heart and soul of the true bourbon lover, and is sure to remain a favorite for generations to come.
Lucid Absinthe Supérieure

Lucid Absinthe Supérieure

Disappointed
Quality
80%
Value
40%
Price
40%
I absolutely LOVE absinthe, so I set out to try as many as I could find, which has generally been a frustrating challenge. I had high hopes for this one, based on reviews (on other sites) and the elevated price. But price doesn’t always equate to preference, and I’m disappointed. I can’t criticize the overall quality of the product, because it has a “sophisticated” flavor. It’s just not a flavor that suits my palate. What I taste is less anise than most absinthes, and more of a cognac kind of flavor additive. Not my cup of tea at all. So I did what I often do, even with some preferable absinthes. . . . I added Dr McGillicuddy’s Root Beer Schnapps. And for those of you who like both licorice flavor AND root beer flavor, it is the best flavor combination ever! Still my go-to drink for greatest tasting cocktail ever! But with Lucid absinthe, it only “salvaged” the drink. Again, Lucid somehow seems very sophisticated, and I’m guessing that many will prefer this flavor profile, but for me, I’ll probably stick with Pernod and (Van Gogh) Absente, and maybe a few others.
Buffalo Trace Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Buffalo Trace Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Wasn't A Whiskey Drinker Until Now
Quality
98.545454545455%
Value
97.454545454545%
Price
95.636363636364%
I've never been a whiskey drinker except for the occasional mixed drink (my preferred mixed drink is (was) Jack Daniels and Ginger Ale. I was introduced to Buffalo Trace while visiting my brother in Tennessee. On the way home to Ohio, a friend asked me if I could find a certain brand of Whiskey. We stopped at Indian Hills Wine & Spirits in Pikeville, Ky. The fine gentlement working there introduced me to Buffalo Trace. They hyped it up so much I bought two bottles to take home. When we got home, I opened a bottle, boured a bit, let it breath and then tried it. Very nice. I'm not a bourbon connoisseur; all I really know is Jack Daniels and a few other popular brands. Buffalo Trace has changed my tasted for bourbon whiskey. I really enjoy drinking buffalo trace and ginger ale (I only use Bundaberg ginger beer). Recently, I was at a local bar and orderd a Jack and Ginger Ale since we do not have Buffalo Trace here in northern Ohio. WOW! I can't believe the difference Buffalo Trace makes when compared to Jack Daniels (Old #7). I had a 1.5 litre bottle of Jack Daniels that I've had since by son and daughter-in-laws wedding three years ago. I just gave it back to them! I ordered a case of BT from here at Caskers. Shipping was slow but everything arrived in-tact. Glad I found an online liquour store to purchase Buffalo Trace! The price here is better than it was at the liqour store in Kentucky as well. I'll be back! :-)
Delord 25 Year Old Bas Armagnac

Delord 25 Year Old Bas Armagnac

A really exceptional value for the quality of experience
Quality
100%
Value
100%
Price
97.142857142857%
In large part, this will echo the review Steve-O posted. I'll extend his comparison to bourbon to include fine Scotch and Irish whisky as well. Some of my favorites are becoming difficult if not impossible to find lately - looking at YOU Springbank and Knappogue! This situation left me wandering around the liquor store today looking for a suitable substitute, and this 25-year-old Armagnac caught my eye. An employee of the store noticed me fondling the bottle and said that he felt it was one of the best brandies they had to offer regardless of price. I decided to take a chance on it, and I am NOT disappointed! For a 40% abv spirit, this has a tremendous range of woody, fruity, aromatic flavors and aromas to offer, and it only gets better with time in the glass. For the $70.00 I paid for it, this is one of the best bargains I've found in a long, long time. Because of this Armagnac, in the future I may be spending less time browsing the Scotch aisle. It really feels like making an adjustment and finding there's little if any compromise.
Island Company Rum

Island Company Rum

the way it should be
Quality
100%
Value
92%
Price
100%
I dont know why its taken me so long to find at last the single most beautifully smooth rum on the planet but damn am I glad that I have at last.

i have always loved rum. when I was younger I first found captain morgans and eventually stepped up to Barbancourt and Mount Gay occasionally.

My heart sings with gladness for those brands as they are great, but for where I am in my life island company rum just is another level compared to everything else. This is it. Full Stop. The last rum I will ever drink.

its so damn good the only thing I think about when drinking it is how good it is - how smooth it is - how clean it is.

its bottled magic. seriously.

i was on the fence about posting this review at all; the way I feel about Island Company Rum the same way I feel about a band I just discovered that is AMAZING that I know will blow up and right now I kind of want to keep that a secret for a minute.

Like that band, island company rum just hasn't quite yet been discovered by everyone else and I kind of want that secret to keep just a bit longer....

Island Company Rum is the solution to the rum problem you didnt know you had.

hyperbole notwithstanding, its that damn good.



Freeland Spirits Bourbon Whiskey

Freeland Spirits Bourbon Whiskey

Terrible
Quality
87.692307692308%
Value
86.153846153846%
Price
81.538461538462%
I was baffled there wasn't a poor review of this whiskey that existed so I really felt compelled to keep people from buying this as a gift. I hear their Gin is pretty decent but this whiskey is hot and unbalanced. It's described as having a clove back-bone, but really, the pinot barrel made the juice a bit too cloying and ethanol-forward. Acrid, sour, spicy, and unbalanced, and unpalatable. They may have just cut the tails of the run weird on the batch that I received which may be a one-off because my suspicion is it came out at cask-stregnth and not 46%. That being said, I cut it with a lot of water to try to save the dram and it was still undrinkable.

Reminds me of an Irish whiskey which would make sense from a distillery that started with a Gin focus. The age (3years) isn't too bad, but Freeland's methodology needs a lot of rehashing or barrels need some serious rectification to bring more balance to this bottle and we may honestly throw it away.
The Glenlivet Archive 21 Year Old Single Malt Scotch Whisky

The Glenlivet Archive 21 Year Old Single Malt Scotch Whisky

Disappointing and overpriced.
Quality
80%
Value
60%
Price
60%
"Rich, luxurious aroma of pine, raisins and sandalwood. Notes of brown sugar, walnuts and honey on the palate, that are well-complemented by notes of dried fruits, Christmas cake and baking spices. Finish is long and sweet, with a hint of chewy leather, ginger and oak". Quite a list of 'tastes' that are not apparent nor discernible. Fruit, Christmas Cake and spices, walnuts, brown sugar, pine, honey, raisins, sandalwood, ginger, oak and a 'hint' of chewy leather. Snobbish trash talk for all the hints I gather is chewy leather with the typical Scotch aroma predominant. I will say it is smooth and the finish does linger a bit and that's the best I can do.. I'm not new to Scotch Whiskey blended or single malt and I've been imbibing for over 60 years. Whiskey is NOT wine. Trying to give it all these superlatives like a well aged bottle of vintage wine is an exercise in futility. I had my first bottle of Glenlivet 12 year old, back in '75. The taste has never been the same since. Back then, Single Malts were not the 'in' thing to drink and describing all the 'hints' of flavors contained therein would have made whiskey drinkers laugh. Quality, to my mind and taste has gone down hill due to mass production and demand. I was expecting something very special with this 21 year old Scotch. It's not much different then an ordinary bottle of 12 year old. In short, if you are thinking of spending 25 thousand dollars for a bottle of 50 year old, I suggest you demand a wee dram prior to your purchase.
La Fée Absinthe Parisienne

La Fée Absinthe Parisienne

So far, my favorite absinthe
Quality
80%
Value
80%
Price
60%
I'm a very light drinker but have wanted to try absinthe for awhile. Ended up buying some from Cheklosovakia and somewhat dissapointed, as the louche effect of adding water was not working, and was one of the main feature's I was looking for. After reading reviews decided to to give the French made La Fee a try. Caskers processed the order quickly with great communication and updates. Had concerns as earlier reviews had said La Fee used artificial colorings, but was happy when the bottle arrived and proclaimed that it was all natural. My first glass demonstrated a huge difference between this and previous absinthes I tried. The louche was opaque and somewhat iridescent. The bouquet was subdued and not very noticeable. The taste was mellow, balanced and pleasant. It was nice and I would not hesitate to purchase again, but really want to try other brands just for comparison.
Talisker 18 Year Old Single Malt Scotch Whisky

Talisker 18 Year Old Single Malt Scotch Whisky

A must have
Quality
84%
Value
80%
Price
84%
As Bob suggests, the first reviewer either somehow got a bad bottle or is on something. Talisker 18 is a must for a serious Scotch Whisky collection, and it's a favorite of mine. It's more poetic than a list of tasting notes--though the edge of peaty smoke, the sea salt, fruity undertones, and Talisker's signature pepper (worn mild with enriching time) are all there.

But it's the essence of the first warm morning in spring when the storms of winter have stopped breaking over the rocky seashore. It's the rocks the waves can't break, the crisp air that remembers the gale that saturated the wind with rain and sea salt but now has made peace with the sunlight. It's the old friend stepping off a boat. It doesn't beg for your attention because it knows what it is. It waits for the wise and the intrepid to sit still and let it work its magic.
Talisker 18 Year Old Single Malt Scotch Whisky

Talisker 18 Year Old Single Malt Scotch Whisky

A must have
Quality
84%
Value
80%
Price
84%
As Bob suggests, the first reviewer either somehow got a bad bottle or is on something. Talisker 18 is a must for a serious Scotch Whisky collection, and it's a favorite of mine. It's more poetic than a list of tasting notes--though the edge of peaty smoke, the sea salt, fruity undertones, and Talisker's signature pepper (worn mild with enriching time) are all there.

But it's the essence of the first warm morning in spring when the storms of winter have stopped breaking over the rocky seashore. It's the rocks the waves can't break, the crisp air that remembers the gale that saturated the wind with rain and sea salt but now has made peace with the sunlight. It's the old friend stepping off a boat. It doesn't beg for your attention because it knows what it is. It waits for the wise and the intrepid to sit still and let it work its magic.
Old Potrero 18th Century Style Whiskey

Old Potrero 18th Century Style Whiskey

Expensive, but I would recommend it for the whiskey enthusiast that has been around the block a few times and is looking an experience they haven't had before, and would be hard pressed to find anywhere else.
Quality
100%
Value
80%
Price
80%
Old Potrero 18th Century Style Whiskey is first and foremost a Rye whiskey. It's one hundred percent Rye mashbill places its palate in the realm of Whistlepig or High West, with a few distinguishing aspects.

It utilizes a mash of Malted Rye, which, as far as I know, is unique in all of whiskey.

Up front, this whiskey sets in with the floral, doughy and familier notes I get from my favorite "High Rye" Ryes. Then, all that Malted Rye affects a dark, rich and lingering scotch-like finish on what is only a 2 year old whiskey. Not petty, but malty and fascinating.

The aging is also unique to this whiskey, being aged in not charred, but toasted barrels. This was supposedly the the trend in the 18th century.

All in all this whiskey is expensive, but I would recommend it for the whiskey enthusiast that has been around the block a few times and is looking an experience they haven't had before, and would be hard pressed to find anywhere else.

It would make a great bottle to bring to a tasting party. Great tasting, and a great story to share.
Chartreuse Green & Yellow Liqueurs

Chartreuse Green Liqueur

Nectar. Of. The. Gods.
Quality
100%
Value
83.333333333333%
Price
76.666666666667%
The first impression is of the color, a chartreuse clarity that grabs your eyes and holds them. One can see why the color was named after the liquor. Upon opening the bottle I was struck by the complex array of aromas that literally assailed my nostrils. After the initial rush, I was able to settle into it and enjoy the pleasant floral tones of the many herbs that comprise this liquor. It was recommended that we sip this liquor cold over ice, so I splashed some over 3 ice cubes. The first sip was both harsh, yet smooth, with medicinal overtones. The flavor developed in the mouth and back of the tongue somewhat slowly and then became this complex array of herbal flavors with a not altogether unpleasant medicinal harshness. We slowly savored this and noticed that as the ice melted and slightly diluted the liquor, the harshness disappeared and we were left with a very smooth complex liquor that had excellent mouth feel. The full array of flavors developed slowly and the floral notes changed the longer one savored the sip on the tongue. With 130 herbs, the combinations of herbal notes was complicated and intense. As with most liquors, this one left a warm feeling in the throat and stomach after swallowing. Without a doubt, the best, most satisfying and sophisticated liquor we have ever enjoyed.
Lot No. 40 Canadian Whisky

Lot No. 40 Canadian Whisky

Women’s Whisky World Tasting Notes @chantaillemarie
Quality
100%
Value
100%
Price
100%
Colour: tawny caramelized onion
Nose: moderate amounts of ethanol, vanilla, caramel, marzipan, peppercorn, cotton candy, taffy, and candied yam.
Palate: incredibly smooth and rich with all of the sweetness on the nose. Ethanol and the spice of the high rye mashbill are rather present.
Finish: moderately long, sweet and spicy leaving a partial dryness.
With H2O: a few mls smoothes out the ethanol leaving a more accessible dram. The spice of the rye is forward. The foundation of this dram is the symphony of sweeter notes available on both the nosing and palate. Personally, I prefer this dram with water because there is less distraction from ethanol allowing the drinker to access the full flavour profile of the dram.
Overall Thoughts: This is a robust rye, one definitely for the experienced Canadian 100% rye mashbill. Certainly, it will “taste good” to anyone with a penchant for whiskies, but to be truly appreciated you need to spend quality time with this dram. I would be inclined to serve it with an aperitif prior to a business supper amongst colleagues. Especially with the addition of water this is a definite crowd pleaser for a group of whisky drinkers.
Myrtle Bank 10 Year Old Jamaican Rum

Myrtle Bank 10 Year Old Jamaican Rum

Myrtle Bank received a “Double Gold” The San Francisco World Spirits Competition 2021
Quality
100%
Value
100%
Price
100%
The San Francisco World Spirits Competition (SFWSC) is one of the world’s most prestigious spirits competitions. It’s noted both for the quality of its judges, many of whom are renowned experts in their fields, with decades of industry experience, and the scope of the different spirit categories that it judges.

Myrtle Bank received a “Double Gold” Awarded to the entries that receive a Gold medal rating by all members of the judging panel; these are among the finest products in the world.

Myrtle Bank Rum set out to fill in the gaps left by major producers with niche releases and long-aged bottlings from Jamaica.

The name harkens from the time when Myrtle Bank hotel was the social epicenter of Kingston in the 1920s and 30s. Built in the late 1800s, the hotel was one of the grandest in the Caribbean and was famous for its Rum Punch.

Over the last 10 years Myrtle Bank 100% copper pot-still distilled rum has been aging in ex-Bourbon barrels in the UK and is now ready to enjoy. This fine, single estate, single cask pot-stilled rum was made from molasses in Jamaica’s highlands. The absence of added color or flavoring creates a singularly unique and complex profile. From the hand blown bottle to the unadulterated rum, Myrtle Bank brings one back to the handcrafted and uncompromising traditions of a time gone by.

Bottled at cask strength without any added sugars, Myrtle Bank presents as powerful, but unforgettably smooth. Notes of tropical fruits, ripe banana, oak, vanilla and cocoa. Myrtle Bank will leave an impression. (SRP) $99
Myrtle Bank 10 Year Old Jamaican Rum

Myrtle Bank 10 Year Old Jamaican Rum

Author of TIKI “modern tropical Cocktails”
Quality
100%
Value
100%
Price
100%
The Myrtle Bank Hotel – situated in a district of Kingston Jamaica favored by a cooler micro climate, was initially sought out by travellers for it’s comforting respite from the heat. It was among the first to establish itself as a destination for well heeled travellers to the Caribbean, setting the pace and tone for other iconic properties in tropical regions and the experiences within them to follow: Trinidad’s Queen’s Park Hotel, Haiti’s Hotel Ollufson, and Singapore’s Long Bar at The Raffles Hotel. Like all these other destinations, the Myrtle Bank Hotel was famous for a signature drink.

Sadly, the hotel was the casualty of a fast moving fire in 1966 – an incident which made international headlines – and was not rebuilt. Meanwhile, it’s iconic drink keeps the hotel’s legacy alive.

The Myrtle Bank Punch almost single handedly introduced the rum punch to the world, and eventually, the tropical cocktail canon. It’s point of departure was high ester pot still rums – made in the style that made Jamaican Rum highly sought after by international consumers starting in the late 19th century – and tempering it with the addition of sugar, lime, and a liqueur, festooned with a fancy garnish inspired by the look of the Cobbler and Julep, drinks that were among the first to get international press in the mid 19th century. Like any enduring classic, it took this influence and passed it on, inspiring Victor Begeron AKA Trader Vic, to use this template as the point of departure for his “Rhum Rhapsodies” inspiring a wave of cocktails that were initially called ‘Exotic Drinks” that eventually became what we now call “Tiki”.

To further elevate this mixture, the hotel used Cherry Heering – a liqueur that has a brighter fruit profile and a creamier texture when compared to the leaner and astringent cherry pit based Luxardo Maraschino. This move – which anticipated the use of the latter in the Hemingway Daiquiri, is important to note, as the use of liqueurs signified a level of sophistication in mixed drinks that was initiated in the Crusta – which used Orange Curacao and paved the way for the Daiquiri and Sidecar – indicating that the hotel was invested in providing it’s guests with a premium experience in the glass.

The Hotel’s signature cocktail ‘ and its link to the iconic rum culture of Jamaica – is the inspiration for this bottling of a rare 10 year expression sourced from Worthy Park Estate, bottled at cask strength, meant to be enjoyed neat or to shine in cocktails old and new, with no compromise of it’s bold and distinctive flavor.

Why am I excited by Myrtle Bank Rum? Glad you asked! When I launched the bar program at Gladys Caribbean in 2015, the goal was to share the best examples of traditional rums I could lay my hands on. At that time, the pickings were rather slim in this regard, and one of the islands I found myself leaning on the most was Jamaica. As I learned more about rum production, I learned that Jamaica’s rums resonated with me for a reason: unlike the majority of islands, producers in Jamaica continued to use a few key methods that were there in the inception of rum:

Longer fermentation in open air tanks with wild yeast to give the molasses time to fully “ripen”. Think of the smell given off by overly ripe banana skins – the same chemical process involved in the breakdown of sugar molecules is at work here.

Add to this the use of dunder – the remnants of prior distillation runs as well as other natural compost like materials- crushed cane, plant matter, etc, to further enhance and feed this “low and slow” method of cooking down the sugar in the molasses.

Finally – and critically – the pot still – in the case of Worthy Park, newly installed equipment in operation since 2005 that reference equipment dating back from it’s first production runs in 1741 – brings this raw material to fruition.

The result: a rum with a bright, acidic and fruit driven nose, that when given the opportunity to rest in a barrel, will exhibit a range of flavors: savory chestnut, mahogany, and faint leather with a hint of salinity. Punchinesss and creaminess coexist here in an intriguing – and satisfying way, lending itself to enjoyment neat (if cask strength spirits are your thing!), on a rock, or in a range of cocktails.

For aficionados of traditional rums, Myrtle Bank will be a welcome addition to your shelf. For cocktail fanatics of every stripe, this is a great bottle to turn to, be it for straightforward classics like the Old Fashioned, tropical standards like the Myrtle Bank Punch, or bold, far put Tiki drinks.

Cheers to Rum!
Myrtle Bank 10 Year Old Jamaican Rum

Myrtle Bank 10 Year Old Jamaican Rum

Myrtle Bank’s vault-like Rum warehouse sit rows of rare casks, many decades old, some from little known or defunct distilleries. Myrtle Bank set out to fill in the gaps left by major producers with niche releases and long-aged bottlings from Jamaica and t
Quality
100%
Value
100%
Price
100%
As the rum world continues to emerge from the shadows of the tiki bar and step into the spotlight, new brands are popping up left and right. The trick is making sure you're getting the good stuff. Myrtle Bank is a new brand that has begun by bottling a tremendous cask of 10 year old Jamaican pot distillate that has been aging in the UK. The ex-bourbon barrel has imparted some gentle vanilla and coconut which sands the harsher edges off of a robust and flavorful high ester Jamaican rum. I'ts got some funky Jamaican fruit, a bit of leather, tons of spices ranging from herbal to sweet, and a subtle chocolately aftertaste. It's the perfect thing to take back into the dark corner of the tiki bar and mix yourself a drink.
Clase Azul Mezcal

Clase Azul Mezcal

Just damnit...I had *such* high hopes
Quality
80%
Value
50%
Price
60%
Okay, so *legit* my favorite tequila on the planet is Clase Azul Reposado.

The combo of delish caramel flavor + smoothness + that bottle looks so damn cool, is all on point. My friend threatened me to a blind tequila challenge & as predicted...my Clase won big ;P.

Now there's this *nonsense* of the mezcal. Lemme be clear: I *love* mezcal (and also sotol). Smoky + herbaceous + magic. But this was some got damn ridiculous *nothing* special idiocy.

I splurged because lockdown. I'm usually a $200 max on a bottle type of chick. Just on principal. But you know...2020, whatcha gonna do.

Let me be clear: this mezcal was *fine*...which is very much NOT what I'm looking for in a $370+ bottle. LITERALLY could've kept the bottle & subbed out for Kirkland Mezcal and *no one* would have noticed a difference.

BUT...you can't...because the bottle itself is shockingly awful.

Okay, to be fair, the cap is *lovely*, and beaded and quite nice. But the bottle is this bizarre (and VERY porous) black like chalk board consistency, but rougher, and worse, and hurts your hand to hold it & scratches *easily*.

I threw it out.

Ya.

In the *trash*.

Did not even turn into a vase. (Did keep the cap & it's now on my current Reposado bottle...so there's that).

It is *beyond* rare for me to leave a bad review. I would've *happily* become a lifelong customer.

But it rankled me so badly that I had ignored the other reviews on google & went ahead with the purchase, that I thought I'd spare you the pain. If you're reading this far...I hope I did.

On that now...just bought 2 more bottles of the Clase Azul Reposado, so...at least there's that ;P. I do still love the company overall, because...complete win on the tequila.

Now, I just need to find the *actual* equivalent mezcal. Sadly....this is *not* that.
Buffalo Trace Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey (1L)

Buffalo Trace Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey (1L)

New To The Bourbon World
Quality
97.142857142857%
Value
98.571428571429%
Price
98.571428571429%
I’ve recently become interested in bourbons and began reading as much as I could about the various brands. The Buffalo Trace distillery in Frankfort, KY produces some of the worlds best bourbons. Expressions like Pappy Van Winkle, W.L. Weller, Blanton’s. Eagle Rare, to name just a few. Buffalo Trace is their flagship expression and had gotten very good reviews. As the other reviewer pointed out, Buffalo Trace had become hard to get here in PA. Our State Liquor Stores( yes we still have State control of liquor here in PA) were completely sold out and I knew I wanted to try some. So I placed an order with Caskers. The bottle arrived well packed and in short order. After trying several other brands and then the Buffalo Trace, I can tell you that this bourbon is currently my favorite to sip neat or on the rocks. It is an exceptionally smooth bourbon. If you haven’t yet, give this a try. You won’t be disappointed.
Old Rip Van Winkle 10 Year Old 107 Proof Bourbon Whiskey

Old Rip Van Winkle 10 Year Old 107 Proof Bourbon Whiskey

Have had much better at 90 proof, maybe I'm not use too 107 proof
Quality
96%
Value
72%
Price
48%
I have been chasing Van Winkle bourbons for about 5 years. in May of 2019, while on a business trip in Austin TX, I had the occasion to finally taste one of my long sought after bourbons. it was a 12yr old Van Winkle
Special Reserve. I had it neat with 3 drop of water; it smooth, mellow in flavor, did not have hard alcohol smell. It was simply wonderful and worth a penny of the $92 I paid for the shot. Fast forward to the present. I've been trying to find a reasonably priced bottle of Pappy Van Winkle from 10 to 15 years old without luck. i saw what I considered a reasonable offer for 10year old Old Rip Van Winkle.
What a disappointment,especially at the price point I bought at. When I opened the bottle, it had the harsh smell of moonshine alcohol. When I poured it straight Neat, no water drops, the bite was hard, the taste was like woody nutmeg and rye, it had a hell of a burn. Latter I tried, Old Rip on the rocks and it was smoother. My feeling is I shouldn't have to ice down a good bourbon. I'll not buy this year of OLD Rip again. i'll fall back to a 12 year Old Special Reserve, keep looking for a Pappy and continue to enjoy Jerfferson's Ocean 15 and 17 at a tenth of the price point.
Willett Pot Still Reserve Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Willett Pot Still Reserve Straight Bourbon Whiskey

fish says Try Willetts Pot Still Reserve
Quality
98.571428571429%
Value
99.285714285714%
Price
97.857142857143%
Willetts Pot Still Reserve matured an estimated 8 - 10 yrs is a high quality Bourbon expression. I won't try to tell you what tasting notes you might find but I will tell you that WPSR is smooth and delicious at a fair price which is really all I care about. If you get an opportunity to purchase any of the Willetts hard to find 4/6 yr old Bourbons or their Rye at the Willetts suggested retail price count your blessing and buy them otherwise be prepared to float a loan on the secondary market. So far the Willetts availability exception is their Pot Still Reserve which comes in a unique Pot Still shaped bottle generally at a fair price. Try any of their expressions and I think 99.5% of you will be well satisfied with taste and Willetts will help you forget Old Pappy. In conclusion, Caskers is a reliable supplier offering competitive product and shipping prices as well as hard to find expressions.
Regards,
fish - catch and release.
Chartreuse Green & Yellow Liqueurs

Chartreuse Green Liqueur

Extremely Complex
Quality
100%
Value
83.333333333333%
Price
76.666666666667%
Currently writing this review as I'm deeply breathing in the scent of this spirit from a decanter. There's absolutely a refreshing floral tone that's more or less catapulted by the strong evaporating odors brought on by it's proof but also by it's definite status as a Kräuterlikör (herbal liquor) like Jägermeister. Now time for the tasting...

Now since this liquer is probably most similar to absinthe in a general sense, I will use absinthe as the reference to note this drink's differences. I'm drinking it chilled and neat. The digestif characteristics become quickly noticed with this one where the flavor transfers instantly from the tongue to the stomach while still lingering in the mouth. The more you sip the warmer the esophagus and stomach become, but it settles quickly. This compared to absinthe where the drink seems to hit the brain and limbs as instantly as this one hits the stomach. The tasting notes are far less bitter and lasting than absinthe. Where absinthe can take on that kind of almost moonshine finish all high octane spirits have, this high octane liqueur could be said to almost have a cough medicine finish. I will say that this just like many liqueurs has an almost creamy texture compared to spirits.

Apologies in advance to all absinthe lovers and connoisseurs as I do not consider myself one and know my comparison reference could be off-key.
Myrtle Bank 10 Year Old Jamaican Rum

Myrtle Bank 10 Year Old Jamaican Rum

Myrtle Bank’s New 10 Year Old Single Cask Rum is Elevating the Category
Quality
100%
Value
100%
Price
100%
Rum has gotten a bad reputation in recent years, as some brands have relied on misleading marketing, deceptive age statements, and non-disclosure of additives like sugar and coloring to sell their product. But there is dependable, high-quality rum available to drink these days, the latest of which comes from independent bottler Myrtle Bank. The brand is named after the Myrtle Bank Hotel, once one of the most impressive hotels in Jamaica, perhaps throughout the entire Caribbean. Built in the 1800s, the hotel truly reached its pinnacle in the 1920s and ‘30s when it was the epicenter of the thriving social scene in the nation’s capital, Kingston.

Myrtle Bank’s new single cask rum has also reached its pinnacle. The rum was distilled in Jamaica at the country’s oldest distillery in traditional copper pot stills using molasses grown in the highlands. The rum was then put into ex-bourbon barrels and shipped to the UK, where it patiently spent a decade aging. This change in climate allowed for a really delicate maturation process. In the tropical heat of Jamaica, the rum’s character can be overtaken by tannins as it expands and contracts in and out of the wood over the years. In the more temperate UK climate, however, there is less angel’s share, meaning that the rum is able to age more like a fine single malt scotch. As the liquid slept inside these carefully watched oak casks, it picked up notes of tropical fruits, ripe banana, oak, vanilla and cocoa. No coloring or sugar was added to alter the appearance or flavor of this unique single estate spirit, allowing it to shine on its own merits. It’s bottled at 120 proof so the full flavor can be appreciated without being watered down.

Myrtle Bank’s goal is to change the public’s perception of rum and introduce the American market to rare single cask releases, the likes of which were previously only available in Europe. While it might be more expensive to transport this rum on a continent-spanning journey from its Jamaican source, to the UK for aging, and then back across the Atlantic to the US, this journey has helped shape the character of this truly unique and delicious sipping rum.
Roe & Co Blended Irish Whiskey

Roe & Co Blended Irish Whiskey

Well worth investigating, especially if you're fond of sweeter whiskeys
Quality
100%
Value
100%
Price
100%
I ordered a sample of this whiskey as part of a tasting set from Flaviar, and boy was I pleasantly surprised. This is going in my liquor cabinet, as it is much more palatable than Jack Single Barrel, and costs a bit less.

it is slightly sweet (which I like) so if you like Makers Mark (which is my fallback when I'm out bar hopping as you can usually get it as a top shelf whiskey in most dive bars) you will love this.

Nice nose, hints of vanilla and fall fruits (peaches, pears, apples, unusual for a whiskey, normally I'd expect that with wines) with some cardamom and allspice hints underneath.

It's very, very smooth, especially since it is 90 proof, velvety on the tongue with a long finish, vanilla and slight caramel tones with some fall spice flavor (nutmeg, cardamom, pumpkin spices) which would make it great during the holidays. Nice silky mouthfeel, long finish, only a slight burn on the first sip (it is 90 proof), but that fades quickly. Nice complexity for a whiskey that costs less than $40 a bottle generally, worth the upgrade from Makers for sure, as it is alot more interesting.

Going to source this as a regular in my liquor cabinet, may have to give the Makers to friends to make room LOL.
Salcombe Gin 'Rosé Sainte Marie'

Salcombe Gin 'Rosé Sainte Marie'

Simply stunning gins
Quality
100%
Value
100%
Price
86.666666666667%
Two awesome gins from this distillery in England. I’ve seen the photos on their website of their distillery and really hope to visit when I am next over in the UK. It sits right on the water. Worth the cost of a boat just to be able to visit the distillery by water. Now for the gin. I’ve tried both. Their Start Point is the most delicious example of a London Dry I have ever tried. Far better than anything else you can get from the local liquor store. Serve with a slice of ruby red grapefruit for the best serve. Their pink gin isn’t like others I’ve tried. It is dry yet soft and brilliantly aromatic. They don’t use any artificial colors or flavors and no added sugar. Simply awesome and the bottle and label is stunning. I can’t wait to see both of these more wifey available in the US. One distillery to watch for sure.
Suntory Hibiki Japanese Harmony Whisky

Hibiki Japanese Harmony Whisky

Fantastic
Quality
80%
Value
80%
Price
75%
Hibiki still lives up to its potential as some of the best whisky out there; winning several of world whiskey awards to this date as it competes with the best bourbons made internationally. If you get into Japanese Whiskey you have to understand the origins and where it comes from as it tends to note some of the lighter sides of scotch (an isle, island tier flavor). Hibiki has a rich smoothness with full of oak, almond, spice and rich tastes that are completely indescribable. If you want to further enjoy the past flavors of Hibiki, please refer to the age statement hibiki’s that are an entirely rich fulfilled experience.
***European whiskeys do not compare to Japanese whiskey to any extent. *** please understand that Japanese distilleries are being shut down because of the large shortage of Japanese Whiskey. Despite the shortage, the Japanese still rely on quality rather than costs to ensure the best taste for the consumer. That’s why the price is so high, it’s becoming a rarity.

Final words, Hibiki, Yamazaki, Hakushu, Yoichi, Nikka Coffey Grain whiskey, Nikka Malt are all notable whiskeys to look for if you want quality in taste.
Henry McKenna Single Barrel 10 Year Old Kentucky Straight Bourbon

Henry McKenna Single Barrel 10 Year Old Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

4.0 (out of 5.0)
Quality
92%
Value
84%
Price
80%
Henry McKenna Single Barrel 10 Year - 4.0Dried apricot and chili pepper fill the palate with a sweet warm heat although, spices and wood notes are noticiable, the finish provides familiar vanilla and caramel flavors to round the profile. Tail is thin and short.

In 1837, Henry McKenna emigrated from Ireland to the United States. After spending nearly two decades as a farmer in Kentucky, McKenna founded an eponymous distillery in 1855. At the time, McKenna focused on the production of wheat whiskey (the only crop he was harvesting at the time) and was able to distill enough whiskey to fill one barrel each day. As word of McKenna's high-quality whiskey spread, McKenna was able to triple his distillation capacity, and began experimenting with the production of bourbon. Following his death in 1893, McKenna's three sons — Daniel, Stafford and James — began operating the business.

Today, Henry McKenna Single Barrel 10 Year Old Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey honors the rich family tradition and pioneering spirit of the McKenna family. The bourbon, which is made from a mash of primarily corn, is the only extra-aged bottled-in-bond single barrel bourbon available today. Pursuant to the Bottled-In-Bond Act of 1897 (27 C.F.R. 5.21), any spirit labeled as "Bonded" or "Bottled-in-Bond" must be the product of one distiller at one distillery during one distillation season. In addition, the Act requires that bonded spirits be aged in a federally bonded warehouse under U.S. government supervision for at least four years and bottled at 100 proof.

Henry McKenna Single Barrel Bourbon Whiskey is matured for a minimum of forty Kentucky seasons (ten years) before each bottle is filled and labeled with its batch and bottle number. Since each bottle of McKenna's Single Barrel Bourbon is bottled from a single cask rather than being crafted from a batch of casks, however, each bottle is slightly different and entirely interesting.
The Macallan Oscuro Single Malt Scotch Whisky

The Macallan Oscuro Single Malt Scotch Whisky

Best Scotch I've had the pleasure of tasting
Quality
80%
Value
70%
Price
70%
I've been lucky enough to taste well over 100 scotches premium end through the past decade, and while I should note that I do lean towards sherried whiskies and away from peat (generally a fan of a number of bottling from Glendronach, Glenfarclas, Glenrothes, and Macallan), The Macallan Oscuro tops my list.
I've tasted it head to head with some top competition, including The Macallan 25 (which comes in at ~$500 to $1,000 more) and the Glendronach 33 year (now discontinued), which also comes in at ~$500 to $1,000 more), and while those are superb drams, the Oscuro is smoother, richer and simply more flavorsome. I've never before tasted a whisky that combines the rich depth of flavor the Oscuro has with an unreal buttery smoothness.
I'll finish by saying that whenever I've had friends taste the Oscuro, they are equally impressed (every single one). If you get the chance and you have a few $$'s to splurge on one of the best whiskies money can buy -- buy this. You won't be disappointed.
Howler Head Kentucky Straight Banana Bourbon Whiskey

Howler Head Kentucky Straight Banana Bourbon Whiskey

None for me, thanks.
Quality
71.111111111111%
Value
68.888888888889%
Price
77.777777777778%
I received a sample bottle of this in a shipment today. For reference, in that shipment was a bottle of Jameson Black Barrel, High West Double Rye, High West Rendezvous, Buffalo Trace, and a bottle of Macallan double cask 12 years. The Jameson Black Barrel, out of all of these, is my favorite. So of course, a Kentucky straight bourbon whiskey infused with banana is right up my alley.
I tried it, and I must say, that it is the finest banana flavored whiskey I have ever had. Also the only one, but still true. If I ever wake up 25 years younger, still with a taste for mountain dew, I will certainly choose this over 99 bananas any day of the week. Well, maybe not.
I understand, from an economics side, why companies would flavor alcohols like this. I noticed it with vodkas, then rums. These are meant for younger people, with a higher tolerance for candy. These are not for me. If you make a whiskey (or a vodka or rum) that would be improved by adding flavors used to make jolly ranchers, I don't want any. If I want a jolly rancher, I'll have one. If I want a whiskey, I'll not be reaching for this.
Howler Head Kentucky Straight Banana Bourbon Whiskey

Howler Head Kentucky Straight Banana Bourbon Whiskey

Banana Infused Indeed!
Quality
71.111111111111%
Value
68.888888888889%
Price
77.777777777778%
I received a surprise mini-bottle sample of this from Caskers upon receipt of my last bourbon order. Despite my extreme dislike of anything banana, I couldn't let this go to waste. So I took this sample of Howler Head Banana Infused Kentucky Straight Bourbon, 40% ABV, sucked it up and gave it a taste test. Surprise! Mikey Likes it! The nose had a definite sweet banana bread aroma going for it with a little spice. The taste was just like the nose; very sweet, syrupy banana-crazy flavor -- but in a good way. It was like I imagine Bananas Foster dessert in a glass would taste like. It was more like an after dinner liqueur than a run of the mill bourbon -- waaay too easy to drink. And remember, I don't like bananas! It left a long sweet finish with only a hint of spice to it -- possibly cinnamon. Other flavors one expects of bourbon are missing or hidden by the banana flavor though. But, If I liked bananas and/or was a beginner bourbon enthusiast, and wanted a sweeter than usual, banana bourbon experience, I would seek this out wherever it may be. Might be real good as a mixer in some tropical drinks also.
McCarthy's Oregon Single Malt Whiskey

McCarthy's Oregon Single Malt Whiskey

McCarthy’s Single Malt- An education in peat.
Quality
100%
Value
100%
Price
100%
Living in the U.S. I get really excited at the opportunity to taste an interpretation of Scotch-style whiskey so strongly influenced by my homeland. McCarthy’s Single Malt also combines many of the elements I seek out when choosing from among my favorite Scotches: a mineral earthiness, fruits and bitter chocolate. The peat is (in my opinion) appropriately restrained while still very apparent. Where other peated whisk(e)y seeks to fill my mouth with ash, McCarthy’s uses its peat to transport and complement malt’s other basal notes, conjuring images of orchards and old wood-mills so ubiquitous to the northwest United States. It is a worthy fusion of old and new world distillery magic, dripping with nostalgia for a world that never entirely existed, save for in our thoughts and in our glass. Thank you folks for the epic sip.
Proper No. Twelve Irish Whiskey

Proper No. Twelve Irish Whiskey

Smooth
Quality
68.888888888889%
Value
71.111111111111%
Price
71.111111111111%
I bought my first bottle of this when Conor fought Khabib awhile ago. Before that I was really into cognac and wasn’t much of a whiskey drinker. Once I had this I stopped drinking cognac. I just like this stuff. It is really smooth, and doesn’t give me hangovers if I have a glass or two like other whiskies. I convince everyone I talk to to try it and every one of them thinks it’s really good too. I notice a lot of “Whiskey fanatics” try to talk down on it but I can’t help but to think it’s because they hate Conor mcgregor and think they too sophisticated to drink something made by a brash celebrity. I’ve tried a bunch of other whiskeys since then because proper twelve isn’t sold everywhere so it would be nice to acquire a taste for something easier to find but nothing comes close to me. I’ve taken suggestions from people that seem to know everything about whiskey and it’s just not as good. Proper Twelve and Buffalo Trace are my favorites as of now.
Dingle Distillery Original Pot Still Gin

Dingle Distillery Original Pot Still Gin

An etherial experience!
Quality
100%
Value
100%
Price
100%
While visiting Ireland this summer, we were in Dublin and we ventured to the oldest pub in Ireland (or so they claimed..ha) - Brazen Head. It was a wonderful place and after ordering my usual G&T...the bartender said he would make me the BEST G&T THAT I HAVE EVER HAD! Well he presented me with a Dingle gin G&T! It was unique and fantastic. The Dingle gin was voted "The best gin for 2019" in Ireland! While in Ireland, we traveled to the actual Dingle factory hoping to purchase some at the factory but they were not permitted to sell it at that location. We did purchase it at a package store and enjoyed it during our month-long vacation. We bought a bottle at the airport to take home but gave it to our friends as a gift for their kind airport transport and keeping our car for the month. BUT, that left us without Dingle gin. We are so happy that "Caskers" carries Dingle Gin, and even-though it is twice the price as in Ireland...we are happy to pay the price! The flavor is so uniquely different from any other gin that I have tasted...you simply have to try it! What a delightful treat. Pair it with a Fever-Tree - lite cucumber tonic (another item that you can find in Ireland but I am still on the hunt for here)... and you will have an ethereal experience!
Little Book Chapter 3: The Road Home Blended Whiskey

Little Book Chapter 3: The Road Home Blended Whiskey

read below
Quality
100%
Value
60%
Price
60%
It is very rare I even tell people about the bourbon I buy and drink and hopefully this does not backfire on me. If I had one word to describe this bourbon it would be "ORGASMIC". I did not expect what was going to happen to me when I took a sip of this bourbon, it was truly an orgasmic experience. I poured 3 fingers and figured that it would last me the evening being the 120+ proof bottle. I then sat down in my leather recliner, kicked my feet up, opened the laptop and started to review the dailly news. With the state of current news in the U.S. of course it did not take long to get a tad bit irritated so I grabbed my glass a little book, chapter 3 took a sniff(it smelled pretty good) to a small sip(being 120+ proof) I did not want to burn my throat or anything. As soon as it hit my lips my mouth exploded in all kinds of flavors, the closely cut hairs on the back of my neck(retired military and never got use to long hair) stood up and I swear to god a rush of endorphines raced through my body. I swear to all that is good if I did not actually know what a climax was I would swear that I just had one. I have been drinking bourbon(some great, some terrible but mostly descent) for 31 years. From Pappys to Jim Beam black label this is the first and only time I have experienced this kind of reaction to drinking a bourbon. Needless to say what was suppose to be 1 3 finger drink for the evening turned out to be 1/3 of the bottle. I went to bed feeling awesome and woke up feeling even better. Since I did not have to work when I woke up I had to try another glass just to make sure it was as good as the night before. Yes it was just as good and now everyday day I look at that 1/2 empty bottle remembering just how good it was and forcing myself not to open it up and save it for a special occasion or at least until my local liquor store gets in some more so I can purchase a few back up bottles.
Parce 12 Year Old Straight Colombian Rum

Parce 12 Year Old Straight Colombian Rum

Expensive Rum but good!
Quality
100%
Value
100%
Price
100%
Here is your average Rum drinker review. Cool bottle, nice to know the Amazon rain forest has gotten another tree as well. I gotta breath...However Parce 12 year Rum was really had to find and really expensive! In fact, if it weren't for Caskers, we wouldn't have been able to even try it.
19 guys really looked forward to trying Parce 12 year at our Fall Rum & Cigar night this September. So I made sure we got it in time. The personal email contacts and updates from Caskers was more than enough to assure me we'd have our Rum.
They were not disappointed! We brought out 3 different Rums to try. The Parce 12 year got emptied first, nuff said! I'm not sure if it was the story of a Father and his 3 sons or the taste that got the best of the guys.
I do have to say for the past 3 years at our Rum & Cigar night we would run the winner of the previous year against two new rums for the following year and one has always taken Top Rum every night. I decided this year to keep it tucked away until half the night was gone. So once the Parce was out and half the Clement Rum was out, I pulled out the Flor de Cana 12 year. Betore it was 11pm they killed it. Like mad dogs, they emptied the Flor de Cana. Might buy Parce 12 year again some day but not anytime soon with it being hard to find and very expensive.
Booker's Small Batch Cask Strength Bourbon Whiskey

Booker's Small Batch Cask Strength Bourbon Whiskey

A really GOOD bourbon
Quality
100%
Value
100%
Price
80%
I don't know all the lingo that everybody uses with tasting notes, but I will say this... I went to a whiskey bar on a Groupon recommendation and had 37 different Whiskey's over. Of 4 hours with lots of water in between and I walked out with an extensive list and notes of what I felt were some of the best whiskeys and Bourbons to try for my home collection and boogers was one of the only ones that I remembered. Now that I have the bottle at home I can say that without a doubt it is one of my favorite go-to Bourbons in addition to Angel's Envy and four roses. Booker's Cask bourbon is a heavy and hot bourbon as a sipper it is quite fantastic. I will add a dash of cool water not more than a third of an ounce making this bourbon one of the best Bourbons I've ever had. And yes I know it's from Jim Beam and I've never had Jack Daniels or Jim Beam Bourbon in my collection but this one is worth it. It is sweet, it is hot, it is vanilla, it is Oaky, it is Carmel, it is almost like a good cigar malt scotch without the $170 price. If you see this, buy it. Just shut up and buy it he will not be disappointed.
See more reviews
stay in touch

Let me stay in touch

Stay in the know about special deals and discounts. Plus, get a $5 off promo code just for signing up.